tprpj;jpukhd tof;FfSk;> tpj;jpahrkhd KbTfSk;

NkNy ehk; Rl;bf;fhl;batw;wpypUe;J XH cz;ikia thrfHfs; vspjpy; Ghpe;J nfhs;syhk;.

Rpy yof;Ffspy; jPh;g;G>muR ,aw;Wk; rpy rl;lq;fs;> ,tw;wpd; top ek; ehl;by; /ghrp];Lfspd; jpl;lq;fs; nray;fs; ,it mq;fPfhuk; ngw;W tUfpd;wJ.

ehk; Vw;nfdNt Rl;bf;fhl;ba ePjpgjp N`h];ngl; RNu\; mtHfs; ,g;gbr; Rl;bf;fhl;Lfpd;whHfs;:

"Thus, the issue of Ramajanma bhoomi was kept alive by an order of the Supreme Court! It is the judiciary that kept this issue alive since 1949, by passing a series of orders which only farassed the Hindu community over the other. This trend set by the judiciary was to be exploited later by the communal elements in political parties and to be hijacked and monopoliesed as their exclusiue agenda by the Sang Parivar since about 2980"

‘Your Lordships Beware!’

By Justice Hosbet Soresh

Communalism Combat, sep2002

,jd; nghUs;:

"',g;gb ,uhkH gpwe;j ,lk; vd;w gpur;rpidoa capUld; itj;jpUg;gJ cr;r ePjpkd;wj;jpd; Mid xd;Wjhd;. 1949 KjNy ,e;jg; gpur;rpid capUld; itj;jpUg;gJ ePjpj;Jiwjhd;. EPjpj;Jiw njhlHe;J gpwg;gpj;j Mizfs; Vida rKjhaj;jpw;Fr; rhjfkhditahf ,Ue;jd.,jdhy;jhd; ,e;jg gpwr;rpid ,d;wsTk; capUld; ,U;fpd;wJ.ePjpj;Jiw cUthf;fpj; je;j #o;epiy gpd;dH murpay; rf;jpfs; gad; gLj;jpf; nfhz;ld.

,e;jr; #o;epiyia rq;ghpthH 1980 Kjy; Koikahf jq;fsjhf;fp Mjhak; Njbf; nfhz;ld.""

(ePjpgjp Nfh];ngl; RNu\;> fk;A+dyprk; fhk;ghl;> nrg; 2002)

,e;jg; gpd;dzpapy;jhd; ,e;Jj;Jth xU kjky;y mJ xU tho;f;if newp vd Kd;dhs; cr;rwPjpkd;w gjpAk;-,e;ehs; Njrpa kdpj chpik fofj;jps; jiytUkhd J.S.tHkh toq;fpa jPHg;gpidg; ghHj;jp; Ntz;Lk;.,jid rl;l epGzH jh`pH k`%j; ',e;Jj;Jt jPHg;G" vd;Nw miof;fpd;whH.(Religion and Law Review by los,vol.6.1996)

mNj mbg;gilapy;jhd; rptNrdh jiytH ghy;jhf;Nu kPjhd tof;Ffisg;ghh;j;jpl Ntz;Lk;.,e;jpahtpy; ele;j ,dg;gLnfhiyfspy; F[uhj;jpw;F Kd;dhy; Kjy;,lj;ijg; gpbj;Jf; nfhz;lJ 1192-1993k; Mz;L gk;gha ,dg;gLnfhiyfs;jhk;.,it ghghp k];[pj; ,bg;igj; njhlh;e;J elj;jg;gl;lit.

,ijj; jdJ gj;jphpf;ifahd rhk;dhtpd; top nra;J fhl;bdhh; me;jg; gj;jphpf;ifapd; top ,e;j tFg;Gthj jPtputhjj;jpw;F kf;fisj; J}z;bf; nfhz;Nl ,Ue;jhH. mNjNghy; gk;gha; ,dg;gLnfhiyia elj;jp Kbj;jhh;.

,j;jidiaAk; ,e;j ehl;bypUf;Fk; midj;J rl;lq;fisAk; J}f;fp tPrptpl;L nra;jhH rptNrdh jiytH ghy;jhf;fNu!

mg;NghJ kfhuh\;buhit Mz;L nfhz;bUe;j fhq;fpu]; muR ghy;jhf;fNu kPJ ve;j eltbf;ifiaAk; vLf;ftpy;iy.

,jdhy; Mj;jpukile;j ,uz;L %j;j Fbkfd;fs; kuhl;ba ePjpkd;wj;ij mDfpdhHfs;. ghy;jhf;fNuapd; gj;jphpf;ifahk; rhk;dhtpypUe;J Nghjpa rhl;raq;fisAk;> Mtzq;fisAk;> epUgzq;fisAk; ePjpkd;wj;jplk; xg;gilj;jhH. ,j;jidiaAk; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; xg;gilj;Jtpl;L ghy;jhf;fNu kPJ tof;F njhlu(fhq;fpu]; muir) kuhl;ba khepy muirg; gzpf;Fk;gb cj;juT Nfl;lhHfs;. Mdhy; kuhl;ba caH ePjpkd;wk; tprpj;jpukhdnjhU jPHg;ig toq;fpw;W. me;j jPHg;gpy; ,g;gbf; Fwpg;gpl;lJ:

''ghy;jhf;fNu K];y]k;fisj; jhf;f Ntz;Lk; vdj; J}z;b jdJ gj;jphpf;ifapy; [dthp 9>1993 md;W vOjpaJ> vy;yh K];ypk;fSf;Fk; vjpuhdJ my;y. khwhf mit Njr tpNuhj K];ypk;fSf;F kl;LNk vjpuhdit.""

,jpy; kpfTk; NtjidahdJk; tUj;jk; kpFe;jJk; vd;dntdpy; ,e;jj; jPHg;Gf;F vjpuhf> cr;rePjpkd;wj;jpy; jhf;fy; nra;ag;gl;l rpwg;G kD(Special Leave Petition – SPL) cr;r ePjpkd;wj;jpy; Kw;whf js;Sgb nra;ag;gl;lJjhd;.

,e;j tof;Ffs; ifahsg;gl;l KiwNa ehk; NkNy Fwpg;gpl;l ePjpgjp N`h];ngl; RNu\; mtHfs; ,g;gbf; Fwpg;gpLfpd;whH: Kill, Loot, Forget.mjhtJ nfhiy nra;> nfhs;isab> kwe;J tpL vd;gjhfj;jhd; mtHfspd; nfhs;if ,Ue;jJ.

1992 - 1993 gk;gha; gLnfhiyfis Kd;dpd;W elj;jpa ghy;jhf;fNuapd; tptfhuk; mj;NjhL Kbe;J tpltpy;iy. NkNy nrhd;dJ ePjpgjp = fpU\;zh mtHf;s toq;fpa jPh;g;gpd; mbg;gilapy; ifJ nra;ag;gl;lhh;. gpd;dh; tpLtpf;fg;gl;lhh;. mth; tpLtpf;fg;gl;lJ rpy rpy;yiu jtWfs; mtHkPJ jhf;fy; nra;ag;gl;l Fw;wg;gj;jphpf;ifapy; ,Uf;fpd;wd vd;gNj. ,g;gb tpl;lJ jtU vd;W jhf;fy; nra;ag;gl;l kDit ,d;W tiu tprhuidf;F vLj;Jf;nfhs;stpy;iy gk;gha; ePjp kd;wk;.

,e;j Ntjidia ntspNa nfhl;b ,Ug;gtH Kd;dhy; gk;gha; ePjpkd;w ePjpgjp eLtHjhd;.

ghghp k];[pj; ,bf;fg;gl;l gpd;dzpapy; eurpk;kuht; muR tp\;t `pe;j; ghp\j;> MH.v];.v];.Nghd;w mikg;Gfisj; jil nra;jJ.gpd;dH ,e;jj; jilfis rl;lg;gb nry;Ygbahf eLth; kd;wj;jplk; tpl;lhh;. me;j eLtH P.K.ghhp vd;gtHjhd;.,tH nly;yp cah; ePjp kd;wj;jpypUe;J Xa;T ngw;w ePjpgjp.

,e;j eLtH tp\;t `pe;j; ghp\j; kPJs;s jilia rhp fz;lhh;.Mdhy; Mh;.v];.v];.kPJs;s jilia ePf;fpdhh;.

tp.`p.g.kPJs;s jilia CH[pj; nra;Ak;NghNj mjw;Nfhh; ew;rhd;wpjOk; toq;fpdhh;. ePjpgjp P.K.ghhp mth;fs; tp.`p.g.itg; gw;wpf; Fwpg;gpLk;NghJ:

"The laudable objects pursued by VHP" mjhtJ> tp\;t `pe;J ghp\j; Nkw;nfhs;Sk; ghuhl;lj;jf;f ,yl;rpaq;fs;’ vdg; ghuhl;bdhh;.

Mh;.v];.v];.i[g; gw;wpf; Fwpg;gpLk;NghJ:

"Theword Hindu has been firmly imprinted in our national mind was radiantly reflected in our freedom struggle against the British as well. The fight was essentially for certain ideals associated with the word Hind, and not for mere political in dependence or economic rights."

'',e;J vd;w nrhy; ekJ Njrpa kd epiyapy; Mokhfg; gjpe;Js;sJ. mJ ekJ tpLjiyg; Nghuhl;lj;jpy; gpufhrkhfg; gpujpgypj;jJ. Mq;fpNyah;fSf;nfjpuhd Nghuhl;lj;jpYk; ,JNt ,g;gbg; gujpgpypj;jJ. me;jg; Nghh; ep;r;akhf rpy ,yl;rpaq;fSf;fhfj;jhd;. me;j ,yl;rpaq;fs; `pe;J vd;w nrhy;NyhL njhlHGilaJ my;yhky; me;jg; Nghh; murpay; Rje;jpuj;jpw;Nfh nghUshjhu chpikfSf;Nfh my;y.""

ek; ehl;bd; Gujhd gs;spthry; xd;iw ,bj;J> kj ey;ypzf;f G+kpaha; jpfo;e;j mNahj;ahit mkspf;fhlhf khw;wp>cyf muq;fpy; ekJ el;il mtkhdg;gLj;jpa Xh; mikg;gpw;F toq;fpa ew;rhd;wpjo;. mj;NjhL jilAk; ePf;fg;gl;lJ.

,J Nghd;w ghuhl;Lf;fshy;jhd; ,J Nghd;w mikg;Gfspd; mq;fPfhuk; ngw;W ehL KotJk; ,uj;j MW XbaJ ghghp k];[pj; ,bf;fg;gl;l gpd;.

,j;jidf;Fkpilapy; 2002 khHr; khjk; ele;j FsUgbfspy; kj;jpa muRk;> mjpy; gpujkuhf mkHe;jpUf;Fk; th[;ghapAk; ,d;ndhU ,uj;j Mw;wpw;F toptFj;jNghJ mijj; jLj;J epUj;jpaJ ekJ cr;r ePjpkd;wk;jhd;.

mj;NjhL khHr; 17k; ehs; elf;ftpUe;j ,d;ndhU Mgj;ijj; jLj;jJk; mNj cr;r ePjpkd;wk;jhd;. ,Uf;Fk; muR epHthf ,ae;jpuq;fSs; murpay; mikg;Gr; rl;lj;jpd; jdpj; jd;ikfisf; fhf;Fk; filrp ek;gpf;if ekJ ePjpkd;wq;fs;jhk; vd;fpd;whH ePjpgjp N`h];ngl; RNu\; mtHfs;.

,e;epiyapy; ghghp k];[pj; tptfhuj;jpy; mit toq;fpLk; jPHg;gpd; mbg;gilapy;jhd; ek; ehl;bd; eyd; ,Uf;fpd;wJ. ,e;j ek;gpf;ifapy;jhd; mfpy ,e;jpa K];ypk; jdpahH rl;l thhpaj;jpd; fPo; ,aq;Fk; ghghp k];[pj; eltbf;iff;FO tof;Ffis elj;jpf; Nfhz;bUf;fpwJ.

What is stated in this article is an expert opinion by one of the Retd. High Court Judges and is not mentioned belittiling the Judiciary in the eyes of any one.

ghghp gs;spthry; tof;Ff;fhf tpbay; thrfHfSk;> kdpj ePjpg;ghriwapdUk; ,ize;J 15.04.2001 md;W elj;jpa ghghp k];[pj; tpopg;GdHT nghJf;$l;lj;jpy; epjp toq;fpaij midtUk; mwptPHfs;.

,e;j epjpia mfpy ,e;jpa K];ypk; jdpahH rl;l thhpaj;jpd; rhHgpy; ,e;j tof;Ffspy; thjhLk; ]/gh;ahg; [Pyhdp ,lNk toq;fpNdhk;.

me;j epjp toq;fpa epfo;r;rpapy; tof;Ffis elj;Jk; ]/gh;ahg; [Pyhdp mtHfs; tof;Ffisg;gw;wpa KO jfty;fisAk; toq;fpdhH.mjd; gpwFk; mt;tg;NghJ tof;Ffis elj;Jk; ]/gh;ahg; [Pyhdp mtHfspd; Ngl;bfis tpbaypy; ntspapl;Ls;Nshk;.

me;j mbg;gilapy; ,g;NghJk; tof;Ffspd; epytuk; gw;wp 25.11.02 md;W mtiu njhiyNgrp Kyk; njhlHG nfhz;Nlhk;. Tof;Ffs; gw;wp tprhhpj;Njhk;.

tof;Ffis jpdKk; elj;jp tpiue;J Kbf;f Ntz;Lk; vd;w Kidg;NghL elj;jpf; nfhz;bUf;fpd;whHfs;. tof;Ffs; ehk; epidj;jgb ekf;F rhjfkhfNt efHe;J nfhz;bUf;fpwJ vd;whH.

nghUshjhuk; gw;wp Nfl;NghJ K];y[k; rKjhaj;jpd; MjuT vg;NghJk; Njitg;gLk;. vd;whSk; gzj;hy; vJTk; jilglTkpy;iy. gzk; Njit ,y;yhkYkp;y;iy vd;gjhfj; njhptpj;jhH.

my;yh`; K];ypk;fSf;F ,Wjp ntw;wpia toq;Fthdhf!

ghghp k];[pj; ,bj;j tptfhuj;jpy; #o;r;rp nra;jtHfs; gw;wpa tprhuidnahd;iw ePjpgjp ypgh;`hd; mtHfs; tprhhpj;J tUfpd;whh;fs;.

,e;jf; fkp\d; Kd; mj;thdp>eufpk;kuht; Nghd;wtHfs; rhl;rpak; toq;fpAs;sdH.,jpy; jpBnud xU jpUg;gk;. EkJ cs;Jiw mikr;rH mj;thdpapd; kUkfs; nfshp mj;thdp yz;ldpy; tof;fwpQuhf ,Uf;fpd;whh;.

JpBnud ,e;j ypgh;`hd; fkp\Df;F jghy; %yk; xU kDitj; jhf;fy; nra;jhH ,tH. Mjpy; ghghp gs;spthriy ,bg;gjw;fhf rjpj; jpl;lk; NghLk;NghJ jhDk; cld; ,Ue;jjhfTk;>jhDk; fkp\d; Kd; Njhd;wp gy cz;ikfisr; nrhy;ypl tpUk;GtjhfTk; Fwpg;gpl;bUe;jhH.

mj;thdpapd; kfDf;Fk; kUkfSf;Fkpilapy; rz;il. mJ tpthfuj;J tiuf;Fk; nrd;Ws;sJ.,jdhy; thf;F%yj;jpy; Fwpg;gpl;Ls;sJ cz;ikjhd; vd;whYk; khkdhiu mtkhdg;gLj;jp jdf;Fk; jd; fztUf;Fk; ,ilapy; cs;s tptfhuj;ij ,g;gbj; jPh;Jf;nfhs;s tpUk;GfpuhNuh vd;w Iak; vOe;Js;sJ. ,e;epiyapy; ekJ cs;Jiw mikr;rH tof;fkhd ghzpapy; jd; kUkfis kpul;bAs;shH. ,jdhy; ,tUila kUkfs; kUkfs; $wpait cz;iknadj; njhpfpd;wJ.,jpy; nfshp mj;thdp mtUila Kd;dhy; nrayhsh; vd;gJ Fwpg;gplj;jf;fJ. ghghp gs;spthry; ,bg;gpw;F mj;thdpapd; ntwpjhd; fhuzk; vd;gJ Cuwpe;j cz;ik.,jw;F kUkfs; rhl;rpak; Njitapy;iy.